Summary
No government body, and not ACE itself, publishes a count of ACE schools in Saskatchewan. The Ministry of Education registers independent schools by funding category, not by curriculum. Every number in this report is rebuilt from other records.
ACE arrived with a wave of about 30 church schools opened in Saskatchewan between 1975 and 1985. The earliest specific ACE school on record is Christian Centre Academy in Saskatoon, founded in 1982 and later renamed Legacy Christian Academy and then Valour Academy. We found no record of an ACE school operating in 1979 itself.
The Saskatchewan Association of Independent Church Schools (SAICS) is the umbrella group for these schools. Its website called its members "the largest group of church schools in Canada using ACE's individualized, mastery based program." It listed 12 member schools in 2010 and 5 from 2024 on.
Since qualified independent school grants began in 2012-13, between 5 and 8 ACE schools have received direct provincial grants each year, for a total of $27,354,337 to 2025-26. Three more were funded through school divisions as associate schools. One of them, Harvest City Christian Academy, says it has had government funding since 2002.
Four former staff of these schools have been convicted of crimes against students: one at Victory Baptist School in Prince Albert in the 1980s, and three from Christian Centre Academy in Saskatoon since 2023. A fifth former leader of Christian Centre is awaiting trial. Two of those convicted went on to lead other publicly funded ACE schools.
Background
What ACE is
Accelerated Christian Education (ACE), also sold as School of Tomorrow, is an American Christian curriculum company. Fundamentalist Baptist minister Donald Howard and his wife Esther founded it in Texas in 1970. It is now based in Hendersonville, Tennessee. It says it is used in over 6,000 schools in 145 countries, and it sells the same materials to homeschooling families. (Wikipedia)
- Workbooks instead of lessons. Students work alone through booklets called PACEs (Packets of Accelerated Christian Education). Each one has a scripture to memorize and a character trait. Students move at their own pace and must score 80–90% on each PACE test. (Wikipedia)
- Little teaching. ACE classrooms are rows of carrels for private individual study. ACE's own advertising said one teacher with two non-professional helpers could supervise 40–50 students of any grade in one room. (ERIC)
- American content. The materials are written for American students: American history, literature and units of measurement. A Canadian edition exists, but it is not the Saskatchewan curriculum. (Our Sask)
- What it teaches. Science is taught as young-earth creationism. ACE texts have presented the Loch Ness monster as evidence against evolution, defended South African apartheid, and taught that wives must submit to husbands. (Wikipedia) A biology text from Legacy's ACE/SAICS curriculum says humans and dinosaurs lived at the same time. (Global News)
- Outside reviews. In 2016, UK inspectors rated nine of ten ACE-linked schools "inadequate" or "requires improvement." In 2019, the University of South Africa warned that ACE's Grade 12 equivalent may not meet its admission requirements. (Wikipedia)
In Saskatchewan, ACE schools use ACE PACEs up to grade 10, then SAICS's own high school PACEs. Legacy Christian Academy staff wrote those high school courses because the Ministry would not fund schools using ACE at the high school level. (Ministry of Education records obtained through freedom of information)
What SAICS is
The Saskatchewan Association of Independent Church Schools (SAICS) is the umbrella group for Saskatchewan's ACE schools. It writes and sells their high school curriculum from the Christian Centre / Legacy / Valour building at 102 Pinehouse Drive, Saskatoon.
- Founded by the ACE schools. Church schools and homeschooling families formed SAICS in June 1983. It incorporated as a charitable non-profit in 1988. Its bylaws reserve a membership seat for "the Accelerated Christian Education representative for the province." (SAICS; Corporate Registry)
- Called itself an ACE group. From 2010 to 2018 its website described its members as "the largest group of church schools in Canada using ACE's individualized, mastery based program." (SAICS, archived 2010)
- Helped write the rules, then won the funding. SAICS sat on the 1989 Minister's Advisory Board that drafted the independent school regulations. It says it "lobbied successfully for 'Qualified Independent School' status and corresponding partial funding," the category its member schools have been paid under since 2012-13. (SAICS)
- Its own curriculum. Because ACE alone does not meet provincial high school requirements, SAICS "developed Christian curriculum (where none other was available) to match Saskatchewan Learning objectives for high school courses." Legacy Christian Academy staff wrote these PACE-style courses and the Ministry approved them. Member schools buy them, and curriculum sales make up most of SAICS's revenue: $20,907 to $46,003 a year from 2005 to 2022. SAICS also recommends Bob Jones University textbooks. (SAICS; SAICS financial statements; Ministry FOI records; The Carillon)
- Run from Legacy. Its registered office is 102 Pinehouse Drive, its president is Legacy's principal, and its filings list a legacyacademy.ca contact.
Who runs SAICS: the filings
Its registered office has been 102 Pinehouse Drive since at least 2018, the same address Valour Academy lists today. (2025-26 school list) Its president since 2018 is Lou Brunelle, Legacy's principal. (CTV News)
| Date | Record | What it shows |
|---|---|---|
| Aug 2025 | Notice of change of registered office | Office still 102 Pinehouse Drive; contact email now at Prairie Christian Academy |
| Aug 2023 | Annual return for 2022 (filed late) | 9 voting member schools, 2 associate members; contact email at legacyacademy.ca; directors Lou Brunelle (president), Duff Friesen (secretary/treasurer), Amber Boutin |
| May 2022 | Annual return for 2021 | Same three directors; 9 voting members |
| May 2019 | Change of registered office and directors | Office filed as 102 Pinehouse Drive; filed from a Regent Academy email |
| Oct 2018 | Restoral | SAICS restored after being struck off the corporate register; office 102 Pinehouse Drive; contact email at legacyacademy.ca |
| Feb 2018 | Director records | Lou Brunelle becomes president; Amber Boutin (Prairie Christian Academy) joins the board |
| 2009 | Director records | Duff Friesen (Regent Academy, Prince Albert) becomes secretary/treasurer |
| 2005–2022 | Reviewed financial statements | Curriculum sales are most of its revenue, $20,907–$46,003 a year; every set of notes says it "develops and provides a source of educational curriculum materials for the use of church schools" |
| Apr 1988 | Incorporation | SAICS Inc. registered as a Saskatchewan charitable non-profit, entity 208873 |
Source: Saskatchewan Corporate Registry filings for entity 208873, and SAICS financial statements for 2005–2008, 2011–2012, 2016–2017 and 2019–2022, reviewed by accountant Bryan L. Sly.
Part 1
How many ACE schools
The schools
Twenty schools can be tied to ACE, once renamed schools are merged. Eight received direct provincial grants, three were funded through school divisions as associate schools, and nine never appear in Public Accounts. Queen City Church Christian Academy (Regina) and Kindersley Christian Academy appear in ACE Canada's own 2004 school locator for Saskatchewan. Victory Baptist School in Prince Albert and Living Hope Christian School in Estevan, both closed, come from SISCC's own information rather than public records. SAICS member schools are ACE schools. Directory years are the dates of archived captures of SAICS's website, not exact membership dates.
| School | City | Evidence of ACE | Provincial funding | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Christian Centre Academy → Legacy Christian Academy → Valour Academy | Saskatoon | SAICS directory 2010–2026 under all three names; former students and news reports (CBC) | Direct 2012-13 to 2025-26 | Operating as Valour Academy |
| Prairie Christian Academy | Saskatoon | SAICS directory 2010–2026 | Direct 2012-13 to 2025-26 | Operating |
| Morning Star Christian Academy | Regina | SAICS directory 2010–2026 | Direct 2013-14 to 2025-26 | Operating |
| World Revival Preparatory School → Canadian Revival Preparatory School → Elevation Academy | Prince Albert | SAICS directory 2010–2011 (World Revival), 2013–2018 (Canadian Revival), 2022–2026 (Elevation) | Direct 2014-15 to 2025-26 | Operating |
| Northeast Christian Academy | Melfort | SAICS directory 2022–2026 | Direct 2020-21 to 2025-26 | Operating |
| Grace Christian Academy / Grace Christian School | Saskatoon | SAICS directory 2010 to Jan 2024 | Direct 2012-13 to 2022-23 | Registration cancelled 2022 |
| LifeWay Christian Academy (also known as Pathways) | Saskatoon | SAICS directory 2010 to Jan 2024 | Direct 2012-13 to 2022-23 | Not on the 2025 school list |
| Prince Albert Family Church Academy → Regent Christian Academy (Regent Academy) | Prince Albert | SAICS directory 2010–2013 (Family Church), 2015 to Jan 2024 (Regent); operated by Embassy Church (see Charges) | Direct 2012-13 to 2023-24 | Not on the 2025 school list |
| Harvest City Christian Academy | Regina | SAICS directory 2010–2018 | Associate Regina Public Schools; the school says it "operated without government funding until 2002" (HCCA) | Operating |
| Heritage Christian School | Battleford | SAICS directory 2010–2018 | Associate Living Sky School Division (News-Optimist); start date not found | Operating |
| Meadow Lake Christian Academy | Meadow Lake | SAICS directory Oct 2013 | Associate Listed as an associate school on the 2026-27 list; division and start date not found | Operating |
| Almond Tree Christian Academy | Canora | SAICS directory 2013 to Jan 2024 | None found | Not on the 2025 school list |
| Yorkton Christian Academy | Yorkton | SAICS directory 2010–2018 | None found | Not on the 2025 or 2026-27 school lists |
| Westdale Christian School | Saskatoon | Reported using ACE for grades 1–9 (Our Sask) | None found | Moved into the Legacy building in 2024 |
| Nipawin Christian Centre (Nipawin Christian School) | Nipawin | ACE Canada school locator, 2004; SAICS directory 2010–2011; StarPhoenix independent schools list, 2007 | None found | Not on later lists |
| Victory Christian Academy | Saskatoon | SAICS directory 2010–2011 | None found | Not on later lists |
| Queen City Church Christian Academy | Regina | ACE Canada school locator, 2004 (archived) | None found | Not on later lists |
| Kindersley Christian Academy | Kindersley | ACE Canada school locator, 2004 (archived) | None found | Not on the 2006-07 list or later lists |
| Victory Baptist School | Prince Albert | SISCC information; a newspaper report names "the Victory Baptist Church school" and a student there in 1982 (see Charges) | None Closed before 2012 funding | Closed |
| Living Hope Christian School | Estevan | SISCC information; opening date not yet confirmed | None found | Closed |
"Direct" means grants paid by the province and listed by name in Public Accounts. "Associate" schools are funded at 80% of the per-student average through a school division. "None found" means no payment of $50,000 or more appears in any Public Accounts volume from 2011-12 to 2024-25.
Counts over time
Two counts are specific to ACE: SAICS's own member directory, and the schools receiving direct grants in Public Accounts. The other figures count wider groups of schools, for context.
| Period | Count | What it counts | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1975–85 | about 30 | Private religious schools opened (all curricula) | Making the Grade |
| 1987 | 48 | Private schools of every kind, about 3,000 students | Making the Grade |
| Nov 2010 | 12 | SAICS directory, headed "As of February, 2010, SAICS has twelve member schools. It remains the largest group of church schools in Canada using ACE's individualized, mastery based program." | SAICS, archived |
| Oct 2013 | 12 | SAICS directory; Almond Tree, Meadow Lake and Canadian Revival added; Nipawin, Victory and World Revival gone | SAICS, archived |
| Feb 2015 – Aug 2018 | 11 | SAICS directory, under the same 2010 heading still saying "twelve" and naming ACE, while listing 11 schools | 2015, 2018 |
| 2012-13 to 2025-26 | 5–8 | ACE schools receiving direct grants each year: 5, 6, 7, 7, 7, 7, 7, 7, 8, 8, 8, 6, 5, 5 | Public Accounts, Vol. 2 |
| 2012-13 to 2017-18 | 19–20 | Qualified (funded) independent schools of every kind | Cardus 2018 |
| May 2022 – Jan 2024 | 9 | SAICS directory, now headed "As of January 2019, SAICS has eight member schools, all of which use an individualized, multi-grade system of learning." ACE is no longer named. | 2022, 2024 |
| 2021, 2022 | 9 | Voting members reported in SAICS's annual returns | Corporate Registry |
| 2022-23 | 63 / 19 | Registered independent schools / qualified (funded) ones | Making the Grade |
| Jun 2024 – Apr 2026 | 5 | SAICS directory: Valour, Prairie Christian, Morning Star, Elevation, Northeast | 2024, 2026 |
| Jan 2025 | 54 / 20 | Independent schools / qualified plus certified (funded) ones | Provincial Auditor |
Part 2
How much public money
The money
The Government of Saskatchewan paid $27,354,337 in direct grants to eight ACE schools from fiscal 2012-13 to 2025-26, according to Public Accounts. Every one of them appears in SAICS's member directory. The total includes $539,211 in one-time COVID-19 payments in 2020-21.
No ACE school received a direct grant in 2011-12. The qualified independent school category was announced in December 2011 and first paid in 2012-13. The total leaves out the three associate schools, whose funding flows through school divisions and is not shown by school.
Payments rose every year but two until 2020-21, as more ACE schools joined and payments per school grew. They eased after 2022-23 as Grace, LifeWay and Regent left the funded list, partly offset by growth at Elevation Academy. In 2025-26 the five schools still funded received $2,268,999, including $630,374 to Valour Academy.
By school
Christian Centre Academy, renamed Legacy and then Valour, received the most: $8.59 million over 14 years, nearly a third of the total.
| School | City | Total received | Fiscal years paid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Christian Centre Academy → Legacy → Valour Academy | Saskatoon | $8,592,752 | 2012-13 to 2025-26 (14) |
| Prairie Christian Academy | Saskatoon | $5,332,415 | 2012-13 to 2025-26 (14) |
| World Revival / Canadian Revival / Elevation Academy | Prince Albert | $4,744,234 | 2014-15 to 2025-26 (12) |
| Grace Christian School | Saskatoon | $2,476,966 | 2012-13 to 2022-23 (11) |
| Regent Academy (formerly Prince Albert Family Church Academy) | Prince Albert | $1,960,562 | 2012-13 to 2023-24 (12) |
| LifeWay Christian Academy (Pathways) | Saskatoon | $1,631,303 | 2012-13 to 2022-23 (11) |
| Morning Star Christian Academy | Regina | $1,526,149 | 2013-14 to 2025-26 (13) |
| Northeast Christian Academy | Melfort | $1,089,956 | 2020-21 to 2025-26 (6) |
| Total | $27,354,337 |
Totals include 2020-21 COVID-19 payments to Legacy ($188,156), Canadian Revival ($161,511), Grace ($99,286) and Prairie Christian ($90,258). Renamed schools are counted once: Legacy was paid as Valour partway through 2024-25, Regent was paid as Prince Albert Family Church Academy in 2012-13, and no payee named Pathways appears in any volume.
Year by year
Every figure is a payment listed in Public Accounts Volume 2, under Education → K-12 Initiatives transfers, in dollars. Page numbers are the PDF page of each year's volume. A dash means no payment of $50,000 or more was listed.
| Fiscal year | Christian Centre / Legacy / Valour | Prairie Christian | Revival / Elevation | Grace | Regent | LifeWay | Morning Star | Northeast | Total | PDF page |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2011-12 | – | – | – | – | – | – | – | – | 0 | none listed |
| 2012-13 | 299,394 | 106,114 | – | 79,586 | 126,958 (e) | 92,850 | – | – | 704,902 | 79 |
| 2013-14 | 430,304 | 206,030 | – | 148,791 | 161,447 | 104,782 | 110,859 | – | 1,162,213 | 76 |
| 2014-15 | 437,944 | 281,510 | 160,965 | 202,449 | 151,265 | 123,668 | 181,652 | – | 1,539,453 | 74 |
| 2015-16 | 451,786 | 311,476 | 235,711 | 224,488 | 154,333 | 140,310 | 196,432 | – | 1,714,536 | 69 |
| 2016-17 | 406,211 | 329,059 | 252,240 | 269,993 | 148,717 | 156,005 | 151,863 | – | 1,714,088 | 71 |
| 2017-18 | 427,153 | 325,100 | 244,494 | 266,551 | 136,471 | 180,385 | 98,946 | – | 1,679,100 | 69 |
| 2018-19 | 563,563 | 363,548 | 295,899 | 262,211 | 151,926 | 181,712 | 77,790 | – | 1,896,649 | 78 |
| 2019-20 | 699,587 | 382,532 | 286,338 | 261,082 | 167,998 | 181,100 | 89,892 | – | 2,068,529 | 76 |
| 2020-21 | 736,274 + 188,156 (a) | 382,862 + 90,258 (a) | 271,751 + 161,511 (a) | 259,703 + 99,286 (a) | 171,351 | 182,061 | 96,384 | 74,970 (b) | 2,714,567 | 65; 96 |
| 2021-22 | 909,035 | 400,618 | 371,170 | 305,353 | 204,974 | 169,309 | 91,119 | 113,771 | 2,565,349 | 64 |
| 2022-23 | 936,303 | 477,177 | 497,282 | 97,473 | 213,530 | 119,121 | 84,966 | 163,266 | 2,589,118 | 69–70 |
| 2023-24 | 806,682 | 523,333 | 637,645 | – | 171,592 | – | 98,482 | 198,093 | 2,435,827 | 69 |
| 2024-25 | 228,031 + 441,955 (d) | 568,108 | 713,012 (c) | – | – | – | 109,394 | 240,507 | 2,301,007 | 73–74 |
| 2025-26 | 630,374 (f) | 584,690 | 616,216 | – | – | – | 138,370 | 299,349 | 2,268,999 | 79 |
| Total | 8,592,752 | 5,332,415 | 4,744,234 | 2,476,966 | 1,960,562 | 1,631,303 | 1,526,149 | 1,089,956 | 27,354,337 |
(a) One-time payment under Finance, "Emergency Pandemic Support for K-12 Education," 2020-21 Vol. 2, PDF page 96.
(b) Paid to Northeast Christian Fellowship Inc., the academy's operator.
(c) $204,800 to Canadian Revival Preparatory School plus $508,212 to Elevation Academy of Prince Albert Incorporated.
(d) $228,031 paid as Legacy Christian Academy plus $441,955 paid as Valour Academy Incorporated.
(e) Paid as Prince Albert Family Church Academy, Regent Academy's earlier name.
(f) Paid as Valour Academy Incorporated. 2025-26 Public Accounts, released October 29, 2026.
How to read these numbers
- They are a floor. Public Accounts lists only recipients paid $50,000 or more in a year, so smaller payments do not appear.
- Fiscal, not school, years. Public Accounts runs April 1 to March 31. The Ministry said Legacy got $759,825 for the 2023-24 school year (CTV News); Public Accounts shows $806,682 for fiscal 2023-24.
- Not counted: property-tax or charitable-status benefits, capital grants, funding to the three associate schools (Harvest City, Heritage and Meadow Lake), and funding to other Christian independent schools with no ACE evidence, such as Saskatoon Christian School or Curtis-Horne Christian School.
- Scale. In 2022-23 the province budgeted about $9.4 million for all qualified independent schools (CJWW). ACE schools took $2.59 million that fiscal year, roughly 28%.
Part 3
Criminal charges and other events
Criminal charges against staff
Criminal charges have been laid against six people who worked at two of these schools. Four were convicted, one is awaiting trial, and one charge was withdrawn. Five of the six were at Christian Centre Academy / Legacy Christian Academy (now Valour Academy) in Saskatoon. The earliest known conviction involves Victory Baptist School in Prince Albert. A charge is not a finding of guilt.
| Person | School and role | Charges | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Elwood Wenig | Victory Baptist Church school, Prince Albert; "Christian educator." The student lived with his family. | Indecent assault on a male (2 counts) and gross indecency (2 counts), against a 12-year-old former student in 1982 | Convicted Guilty of both counts of indecent assault by a Queen's Bench jury; not guilty of gross indecency (newspaper report held by SISCC) |
| Aaron Benneweis | Christian Centre Academy; athletic director and coach | Sexual assault and sexual exploitation of a student, 2008–2012, beginning when she was 13. Charged Feb 2023. | Convicted Pleaded guilty Oct 2023; two years less a day and three years' probation, Jan 2024 (CBC) |
| John Olubobokun | Christian Centre Academy; director 2003–2007; later at Grace Christian Academy (SISCC information) | 12 counts of assault with a weapon for hitting students with a wooden paddle. Charged June 2023. | Convicted Guilty of 9 counts at trial; 18-month conditional sentence, Nov 2025. Pleaded guilty to 5 more; further 5-month conditional sentence, Dec 2025 (CKOM) |
| Duff Friesen | Christian Centre Academy; principal 2003–2004; later principal of Regent Academy, Prince Albert, until 2022 | 11 counts of assault with a weapon for paddling students. Charged June 2023. | Convicted Guilty of 1 count, May 2025 (six-month conditional sentence); guilty of 3 more, Sept 2026, sentencing pending (CKOM; PA Herald) |
| Ken Schultz | Christian Centre Academy; director and vice-principal; church elder | Sexual assault and assault with a weapon (2023); sexual assault, invitation to sexual touching and assault with a weapon (2024); historical | Charged Pleaded not guilty and denies the allegations. Trial set for March 2027. Not proven (CKOM) |
| Terra MacEwan | Legacy Christian Academy; educational assistant; not a certified teacher | Assault with a weapon on a seven-year-old student with autism, May 16, 2024, two years after the province appointed an administrator | Withdrawn Charge withdrawn Nov 2024 after restorative justice; no conviction (CKOM) |
Two of those convicted moved on to other publicly funded ACE schools after Christian Centre Academy: John Olubobokun to Grace Christian Academy (SISCC information) and Duff Friesen to Regent Academy, where he was principal until the Ministry removed teachers named in the lawsuit for 2022-23 (PA Herald). Both schools faced provincial action in 2022. A search of news reports and Saskatoon Police releases for every school in this report found no charges against staff of any other Saskatchewan ACE school; older cases may only be found in print newspapers.
Other incidents, by school
Each of these schools is run by a church, in the church's building, under the church's pastors and elders. SISCC therefore includes church leaders as well as school staff.
Prairie Christian Academy, Saskatoon: Les Semchuk, principal. Police search; no charges laid. On Sunday, October 20 [2002], Semchuk, 46, put his canoe into the South Saskatchewan River near the Gathercole Centre, saying he was scouting a route for a school trip. His canoe was found capsized near the weir, and police, the fire department's dive team and a plane hired by his family searched for three days. He then phoned his family. He told The StarPhoenix that "stresses" had led him to "apparently fake his own death." Police told him the case was closed and no mischief charge was laid. The school then had about 30 students and was housed at Faith Alive Family Church (StarPhoenix clippings held by SISCC).
Regent Academy (Embassy Church), Prince Albert: how the church and school are one. Regent Academy is "a private Christian school operated by Embassy Church" (PA Herald). They share 888 Central Ave., and Regent's phone number is the one listed for P.A. Family Church Academy, the school's earlier name, in 2006-07. Embassy Church Inc.'s charity returns list a "Christian Day School (K-12)" among its own programs from 1997 to 2020. Its directors have included Glen R. Stead (president), Joan Stead and Paulette Stead; Meghan L. Mayer (president since 2017); Waine H. Thiessen; Duff Friesen (since 2018, while principal of Regent); and Richard A. Potratz (2002–2012) (CRA filings via OpenGovCA).
Regent Academy (Embassy Church), Prince Albert: Ken Schultz's philosophy, adopted from Christian Centre Academy. Family Church Academy published Mandate to Educate by Gary Mason, an Embassy Church director, "Adapted from 'Mandate To Educate' by Ken Schultz," the Christian Centre director now facing charges. The file, dated October 2006, was recovered from the school's old website through the Wayback Machine. It states that "the government has been given no place in the educational process" and that the school is "dedicated to the conditioning of our students in these Biblical standards of morality to the point where they are followed instinctively."
Regent Academy (Embassy Church), Prince Albert: Richard Potratz, church director and elder. Impaired driving conviction. On March 14, 2025, while driving for a charter company, Potratz, 71, drove a bus carrying 52 children from a Saskatoon public school with a blood alcohol level more than twice the legal limit, having also taken prescribed fentanyl and hydromorphone. He pleaded guilty to impaired driving and in January 2026 was sentenced to six months in jail; the judge called it "breathtaking in its recklessness" (CBC). The children were not Regent students. His role as an elder is SISCC information.
Regent Academy (Embassy Church), Prince Albert: Meghan Mayer, lead pastor. 2014 blackface school play; no charges. In 2014, while working at Regent Academy, Mayer directed a school play in which a student actor was put in blackface. It became public in July 2024, when she was seeking the Saskatchewan Party nomination for Prince Albert Carlton. She withdrew and apologized (PA Herald; CTV). No charges were involved.
Timeline
ACE schools went from unregulated church schools in the early 1980s, to registered schools after 1989, to publicly funded schools from 2012-13.
- 1970ACE founded in Texas.
- 1975–85About 30 private religious schools open in Saskatchewan, unregulated until 1989. (Making the Grade)
- 1977Harvest City Christian Academy opens in Regina with 33 students. (HCCA)
- 1982Pastor Keith Johnson moves from Texas to Saskatoon to start Christian Centre Academy on the ACE curriculum. (Canadian True Crime)
- Jun 1983SAICS founded. Its bylaws give a membership seat to "the Accelerated Christian Education representative for the province." (SAICS)
- 1987The Dirks review counts 48 private schools with about 3,000 students.
- 1989Education Act amended: independent schools must register. SAICS sits on the Minister's Advisory Board that drafts the rules.
- 1991Independent Schools Regulations take effect.
- 2002Harvest City Christian Academy, later listed by SAICS, begins receiving government funding; it is now an associate school of Regina Public Schools.
- 2010SAICS lists 12 member schools as "the largest group of church schools in Canada using ACE's individualized, mastery based program."
- Dec 2011Province announces the qualified independent school category, funded at 50% of the per-student average. (Government of Saskatchewan)
- 2012-13First year of qualified independent school grants. 20 schools join, including ACE schools. (Cardus)
- Aug 2022A proposed class action is filed over Legacy; its allegations have not been tested in court. The province puts administrators into Legacy, Grace Christian School and Regent Academy, and cancels Grace's registration. (CTV News, Global News)
- 2023Saskatoon Police charge four former Christian Centre Academy staff: Aaron Benneweis (February), Duff Friesen and John Olubobokun (June) and Ken Schultz (July). Benneweis pleads guilty in October.
- Dec 2023The Children's Advocate reports 63 registered independent schools in 2022-23, 19 of them qualified (funded). (Making the Grade)
- Jun 2024Legacy Christian Academy is renamed Valour Academy, the school's third name. News reports described it as Westdale Christian School moving into the building. SAICS's directory shrinks to five schools. (CTV News)
- Sept 2024A Legacy educational assistant is charged with assault with a weapon on a seven-year-old with autism; the charge is later withdrawn after restorative justice.
- Jan 202554 independent schools: 17 qualified, 3 certified, 14 unfunded registered (all religious, none with certified teachers). (Provincial Auditor)
- 2025Duff Friesen is convicted of assault with a weapon (May). John Olubobokun is convicted at trial and receives conditional sentences (November, December).
- Mar 2026The 2026-27 budget holds qualified independent schools at $7.725M and certified at $9.5M. (Legislative committee)
- Sept 2026A jury finds Friesen guilty of three more counts of assault with a weapon for paddling students.
- Oct 2026The 2025-26 Public Accounts show $2,268,999 paid to five ACE schools, including $630,374 to Valour Academy, the former Legacy Christian Academy.
Gaps in the record
- 1979–2010. Private schools did not have to register until 1989, and the earliest archived SAICS directory is from 2010. The 1987 Dirks review and the 1990 Advisory Board report may name schools; both are cited in the Advocate's report but are not online.
- Associate school funding. Harvest City, Heritage and Meadow Lake are funded at 80% of the per-student average through school divisions, and became associate schools at different times. Public Accounts does not show those amounts by school, so they are not in the $25.1 million.
- Small or unfunded schools. Schools paid under $50,000 a year never show in Public Accounts, so the direct-grant counts undercount ACE schools.
- Older criminal cases. Most of these schools operated in the 1980s and 1990s, before news went online. Cases like Victory Baptist's are only found in print newspapers, so the charges listed here are a minimum.
- Curriculum by school. A freedom of information request to the Ministry for each school's approved learning resources would document ACE use school by school. Since 2023 the Ministry reviews core resources every five years. (Provincial Auditor)
Sources
- Government of Saskatchewan, Public Accounts, Volume 2: Details of Revenue and Expenditure, fiscal 2011-12 through 2025-26 (Education → Transfers → K-12 Initiatives; 2020-21 also Finance → Emergency Pandemic Support for K-12 Education). Examples online: 2016-17, 2023-24.
- Saskatchewan Corporate Registry, Saskatchewan Association of Independent Church Schools Inc. (entity 208873): annual returns for 2021 and 2022, restoral (Oct 2018), notices of change of directors and registered office (May 2019, Aug 2025).
- SAICS reviewed financial statements, years ended December 31 2007, 2008, 2012, 2017, 2020 and 2022 (each with prior-year comparatives).
- Ministry of Education records obtained through freedom of information.
- SAICS website member directory, Internet Archive captures: Nov 2010, Oct 2013, Feb 2015, Aug 2018, May 2022, Jan 2024, Jun 2024, Apr 2026.
- SAICS — About Us.
- Making the Grade: Moving Forward in Independent Education, Saskatchewan Advocate for Children and Youth, December 2023.
- Overseeing Independent Schools, Provincial Auditor of Saskatchewan, 2025 Report Vol. 1, ch. 4.
- Qualified Independent Schools in Saskatchewan, Cardus, 2018.
- Education minister announces funding for new category of independent schools, Government of Saskatchewan, December 21 2011.
- Standing Committee on Human Services debates, Legislative Assembly of Saskatchewan, March 31 2026.
- Accelerated Christian Education, Wikipedia.
- The Shock of the Old: The Militant Church and Education, ERIC ED268221, 1982.
- Harvest City Christian Academy: Who We Are.
- Christian school refocuses structure, Battlefords News-Optimist.
- Harmful curriculum being taught in schools, government funded, The Carillon, 2023.
- Saskatchewan "Independent" Schools: The Sequel, Our Sask, 2022.
- Former private school students demand ban on controversial Christian curriculum, CBC News, November 2022.
- Saskatoon rally to call out public funding of Qualified Independent Schools, Global News, 2023.
- Saskatoon school linked to abuse claims has been shut down, Global News, 2022.
- "It's not a healthy system", CTV News, 2022.
- Another person charged at Sask. private school, CTV News, 2024.
- NDP says redacted report on three independent schools show issues, CJWW, May 2023.
- The Legacy Christian Academy Scandal, Canadian True Crime podcast.
- ACE Canada school locator, Saskatchewan page, Internet Archive capture, April 26, 2004 (screenshot held by SISCC).
- "Saskatchewan Independent Schools, 2006-2007 School Year," The StarPhoenix, January 31, 2007, p. C5.
- Embassy Church Inc., CRA charity filings (OpenGovCA).
- Family Church Academy, Mandate to Educate (Gary Mason, adapted from Ken Schultz), October 2006, recovered via the Wayback Machine (copy held by SISCC).
- Saskatoon Police Service news releases: Feb 2, 2023, June 15, 2023, June 22, 2023, Sept 17, 2024.
- Newspaper clippings held by SISCC: "P.A. teacher convicted on sex charge" (Elwood Wenig); StarPhoenix coverage of Les Semchuk, October–November [2002].
- Fourth person affiliated with Legacy Christian Academy charged by police, CBC News, July 2023.
- Benneweis sentenced, CBC News, January 2024.
- Former Christian school director handed five-month conditional sentence, CKOM, December 4, 2025.
- Sentencing for former Christian school principal to begin Friday, CKOM, October 16, 2026.
- Trial for former Saskatoon Christian school director postponed, CKOM, May 4, 2026.
- Charges laid; mother alleges 7-year-old son assaulted at Legacy Christian Academy, CKOM, September 17, 2024.
- Former P.A. principal facing charges, Prince Albert Daily Herald, June 15, 2023; Regent Academy principal not working in school for 2022-23, August 19, 2022.
- Judge sends Saskatoon bus driver to jail for driving drunk with 52 kids on board, CBC News, January 2026.
- Former candidate apologizes for role in 2014 play, Prince Albert Daily Herald, July 2024.